‘Hellboy’ Director Neil Marshall Doesn’t Think The Character Is Meant For The Big Screen 

Something crooked
Jack Kesy and Adeline Rudolph take a look in Hellboy: The Crooked Man (2024), Ketchup Entertainment

The only filmmaker who has been able to flawlessly bring Mike Mignola’s Hellboy to the big screen, and with acclaim, was Guillermo Del Toro who teamed with Ron Perlman to translate the comics into cinema in 2004 and 2008.

HB2
Ron Perlman has a point in Hellboy 2: The Golden Army (2008), Universal Pictures

RELATED: Rumor: Starring Roles In Guillermo Del Toro’s ‘Frankenstein’ Adaptation For Netflix Revealed

Nobody knows this better than Neil Marshall who signed on for the 2019 reboot starring David Harbour. Unlike Del Toro, Marshall didn’t strike gold as his version, which was more of a job to him than a passion project anyway, wasn’t received well.

It’s a career regret for the Dog Soldiers creator that taught him valuable lessons – one of which is a little surprising. Marshall’s attitude toward how seamlessly and effectively Hellboy conforms to the moving picture has changed.

RELATED: Hellboy Director Neil Marshall Explains What Went Wrong With 2019 Film

“Maybe not, yeah. It could be that it’s not meant for the screen in that sense or in a way that translates from the comic books,” he said when speaking to ComicBookMovie writer Josh Wilding about the failed reboot and his upcoming movie, Duchess.

“I love Guillermo’s movies. I’m not that super loyal to the comic books in the sense that I treat them in their own right. I think they’re good movies because Guillermo is an excellent director and, visually, they’re stunning,” Marshall continued.

Whad they do-Hellboy
David Harbour in the polarizing Hellboy (2019), Summit Entertainment

RELATED: ‘Pacific Rim’ Director Guillermo Del Toro Explains The Impact The Original ‘Godzilla’ Had On Him

Conversely, he is noticing a following develop around his 2019 misstep. “I did my best and what I could with what I had under difficult circumstances, but even now, I was just down in Spain for a film festival and I had loads of people come up to me asking about Hellboy. They screened the film there and, who knows, maybe it will grow a little fanbase,” he recalled.

The Right Hand of Doom is taking another swing at theatrical greatness in the latest reboot. Hellboy: The Crooked Man stars Jack Kesy as the titular demon and is directed by Brian Taylor, one of the filmmakers behind Crank and Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance.

NEXT: Hellboy And Pacific Rim Actor Ron Perlman Says He’s Gonna Stomp Out The Memory Of Donald Trump Like a Cockroach

Mentioned In This Article:

More About: