Judge Rules Against Chris Wozniak In Plagiarism Case Against Warner Bros. Discovery And DC Over ‘The Batman’

The BatMan Joker scene
Batman (Robert Pattinson) seeks Joker's help in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Entertainmen

There is an update on Chris Wozniak’s lawsuit against DC and Warner Bros. Discovery over The Batman. A judge in New York ruled that neither party ripped off Wozniak’s spec written in 1990 as he has claimed since the film came out in 2022.

The Riddler's plan unfolds
The Riddler (Paul Dano) watches as his plan unfolds in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures

RELATED: Matt Reeves’ ‘The Batman – Part II’ Officially Delayed Another Year

US District Judge Paul Engelmayer said in a 45-page decision that the penciler and writer infringed intentionally on copyrights registered to DC, according to The NY Post.

“The story’s use of the Batman character and the surrounding protected elements is an act of clear and blatant copyright infringement,” the decision reads.

Batman (Robert Pattinson) solves The Riddler's (Paul Dano) first riddle in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures
Batman (Robert Pattinson) solves The Riddler’s (Paul Dano) first riddle in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures

RELATED: ‘The Batman’ Actor Paul Dano Calls Superhero Fatigue “A Welcome Moment” In Hollywood

Channeling DC’s countersuit against Wozniak for writing an unsolicited Batman story, Judge Engelmayer added Wozniak had no consent and his story titled “The Ultimate Riddle” and “Blind Man’s Hat,“ “liberally exploits – indeed, is rife with” DC elements and characters.

The similarities between The Batman and his story were written off as “too commonplace” to support Wozniak’s claims.

Similarities include, “serial killers who are loners bent on destroying society, villains who taunt pursuers with ‘clues and riddles,’ and moments of ‘clarity or epiphany’ that propel villains to crime,” notes The Post.

Bat cop-good cop
Lt. Gordon (Jeffrey Wright) and Batman (Robert Pattinson) are on the case in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures

RELATED: Penciler Chris Wozniak’s Lawsuit Against Warner Bros. And DC Over ‘The Batman’ Is Going To Trial

They add Engelmayer “cited movies including ‘Star Wars: Episode III — Revenge of the Sith’ where Anakin Skywalker succumbs to the dark side of the Force and becomes Darth Vader.”

Wozniak has said from the beginning WB obtained his script treatment from an email he sent Batman producer Michael Uslan and rewrote it into an early adventure as opposed to the retirement caper he had drafted.

The judge rejected that claim as “wholly speculative” despite shot-for-shot, beat-for-beat examples Wozniak explored in YouTube videos that were taken down.

Riddler breathe
Riddler (Paul Dano) breathes in after killing The Mayor (Rupert Penry-Jones) in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures

Lawyer for Wozniak, Terry Parker, rebutted in an email, “We respectfully disagree with the court’s decision and are considering our next steps.” “A lawyer for Warner Bros and DC Comics had no immediate comment,” added The Post.

NEXT: DC Penciler Chris Wozniak Accuses Matt Reeves Of Stealing His Original Ideas For ‘The Batman’ Film, Provides New Evidence To Back His Claims

Mentioned In This Article:

More About: