John Turturro Did Not Return As Carmine Falcone In ‘The Penguin’ Because Of The Increased Violence Against Women: “That’s Not My Thing”

Into the limelight
Falcone (John Turturro) is brought down by an assassin's bullet in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros Pictures

The Batman actor John Turturro sat The Penguin out even though Carmine Falcone appeared in the series, but the actor explained why. Though there were a few reasons, one stands out.

Miranda
Gordon (Jeffrey Wright) reads Falcone (John Turturro) his rights in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures

RELATED: James Gunn Casts Rupert Thorne In The Animated DCU, But For ‘Creature Commandos’ And Not A Batman Project

Speaking with Variety about other projects, Turturro revealed he was uncomfortable with the level of violence against women compared to the film. “In the show, there was a lot of violence towards women, and that’s not my thing,” he said.

There were such instances of violence in the movie, especially at the climax when Falcone attacks Selina who was secretly his daughter. It also came to light that Carmine murdered her mother, one of his mistresses.

Bat and Cat in The Batman
Batman and Selina on a terrace in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros. Pictures

RELATED: James Gunn Denies Batman Will Be Middle-Aged In ‘The Brave And The Bold’

Other examples included Selina’s roommate, but Turturro sees a difference between the way things play out on the big screen and the way business is conducted on the smaller scale.

“It happens off-screen,” said the actor. “It’s scarier that way.” Turturro also stated that he did what he set out to with Falcone, which gives the impression he feels he played a complete arc.

Gimp
Falcone (John Turturro) tells Oz (ColinFarrell) what he really thinks in The Batman (2022), Warner Bros Pictures

Scheduling was another factor that led to Shazam! and Sinestro actor Mark Strong stepping in as a younger Falcone who let’s his daughter Sofia (Cristina Milioti) take the fall for his crimes as The Hangman.

When the series picks up, she is now free to muscle in, all the way to the head of the family. This is not good for Oz (Colin Farrell) who has his own plans that involve working with the rival Maroni clan to play both sides. He’s also responsible for impulsively killing Sofia’s brother she had a close bond with.

Colin Farrell as Oswald Cobblepot in The Penguin (2024), HBO Max
Colin Farrell as Oz Cobb in The Penguin (2024), HBO Max

RELATED: Rumor: David Zaslav Suggested James Gunn Make Robert Pattinson The Main DCU Batman

Penguin showrunner Lauren Lefranc addressed Turturro’s reasons in an interview with The Wrap. “I completely respect an actor who doesn’t want to take on a role for whatever their personal reasons,” she said.

“I only want people to join our show who are excited and want to further the story we’re trying to tell. I think Mark Strong did a really fantastic job. He made the character his own and also really honored what John Turturro did,” Lefranc added.

Soft
Mark Strong takes over as Carmine Falcone in The Penguin season 1 episode 4, “Cent’Anni” (2024), Max

However, she says schedules were the biggest factor in preventing Turturro’s return. Lefranc shared as well there is a consensus between her and Matt Reeves about Falcone’s violent nature, and they believe Strong is consistent with what Turturro developed.

READ NEXT: ‘Tulsa King’ Showrunner Terence Winter Reveals The Gotham PD Series Set In ‘The Batman‘ Continuity Was Going To Be A 70s Police Drama 

Mentioned In This Article:

More About: